
Nicolaus Reimers Ursus
1551–1600
Biography
Nicolaus Reimers Ursus—who generally Latinized his name as Nicolaus Raymarus or Raimarus Ursus Dithmarsus—was born on 2 February 1551 at Hennstedt in Dithmarschen and died at Prague on 15 August 1600. A mathematician, astronomer, surveyor, calendar-maker, translator, and writer on logic and algebra, he is remembered chiefly for his geo-heliocentric cosmology and the acrimonious priority dispute that it occasioned with Tycho Brahe. That controversy, although central to his historical reputation, has often obscured the breadth of his mathematical work and the unusual character of his intellectual formation.
Reimers emerged from a rural milieu without the sustained Latin-school education customary among sixteenth-century mathematical authors. The Dithmarschen chronicler Neocorus described him in his youth as a senior farm servant, and later accounts associate him with the tending of livestock. He appears to have acquired literacy, Latin, Greek, mathematics, and astronomy principally through self-instruction. His name nevertheless occurs in the matriculation records of the University of Rostock at Easter 1577. His social and professional advancement depended substantially upon the patronage of Heinrich Rantzau, the Danish royal governor in Schleswig-Holstein, in whose service Reimers worked as a land surveyor at Hattstedt from approximately 1574 until 1584. His earliest publications arose directly from this environment: the Grammatica Ranzoviana of 1580 proposed an unconventional arrangement of Latin declensions, while the vernacular Geodaesia Ranzoviana, printed at Leipzig in 1583, treated practical arithmetic and land measurement. The latter work is noteworthy for its use of a hexadecimal place-value system and demonstrates that Reimers’s mathematical interests developed initially within surveying, computation, and applied mensuration rather than university astronomy.
In September 1584 Reimers visited Tycho Brahe at Uraniborg on the island of Hven. The visit subsequently became the disputed point of origin for Brahe’s accusation that Reimers had obtained surreptitious knowledge of his cosmological arrangement. After periods as a private tutor in Pomerania, Reimers reached the court of Wilhelm IV, Landgrave of Hesse-Kassel, in 1586. There he encountered an unusually productive community of practical astronomers, observers, and instrument-makers, including Christoph Rothmann and Jost Bürgi. Bürgi instructed him in advanced trigonometric computation and communicated elements of the rapid procedure for constructing sine tables later known as his Kunstweg. Reimers, in turn, prepared for Bürgi in 1586–87 an almost complete German translation of Copernicus’s De revolutionibus orbium coelestium. Preserved in the University Library of Graz as manuscript 560 and completed in part by other hands, it is the earliest substantially complete German rendering of Copernicus’s treatise. Its manuscript transmission is particularly significant evidence for the vernacular reception of mathematical astronomy among practitioners who did not depend upon fluent command of Latin.
From 1587 to 1591 Reimers studied and taught at the Strasbourg Academy, offering instruction in arithmetic, geometry, and astronomy. At Strasbourg, Bernhard Jobin printed his principal work, the Fundamentum astronomicum, in 1588. This compact illustrated quarto combined methods for constructing sine tables, the solution of plane and spherical triangles, procedures for astronomical calculation and observation, and an exposition of a new world system. Reimers disclosed only guarded indications of Bürgi’s rapid method, but the book nevertheless participated in the contemporary circulation of computational techniques associated with prosthaphaeresis and the reform of trigonometric practice. Its final section presented a geo-heliocentric arrangement in which the planets revolved around the Sun, while the Sun and Moon revolved around a centrally situated Earth. Unlike Brahe, however, Reimers allowed the Earth a daily axial rotation; he also configured the orbit of Mars so that it enclosed the solar orbit rather than intersecting it. These differences are substantial and prevent the two systems from being treated as simply identical diagrams under rival names.
The simultaneous appearance in 1588 of printed geo-heliocentric schemes by Reimers and Brahe precipitated one of the most bitter disputes over intellectual priority in early modern astronomy. Brahe maintained that Reimers had copied an unpublished diagram during the visit to Hven in 1584. Reimers consistently denied the charge and later asserted both his own priority and the existence of ancient or intermediate precedents for geo-heliocentric hypotheses. Modern scholarship has considerably complicated the older narrative of straightforward theft. The circulation of related configurations and mathematical procedures among Paul Wittich, Rothmann, Bürgi, Brahe, and Reimers indicates a mobile northern-European network in which diagrams, computational devices, observations, and partially formulated hypotheses passed between courts and practitioners. The precise genealogy of Reimers’s system remains contested; what can be established is that his published cosmology possessed features absent from Brahe’s and that the dispute concerned not only geometrical priority but also authorship, patronage, social standing, and the ownership of mathematical knowledge.
After matriculating at Wittenberg in May 1591, Reimers was appointed imperial mathematician at the Prague court of Rudolf II in August of that year, with an associated teaching position and obligations that included astrological work. His Prague activity embraced calendars, prognostications, chronology, mathematics, and courtly occasional writing. The large-format Chronotheatron, seu Theatrum temporis, printed at Prague in 1597, reflects his interest in the mathematical and providential ordering of historical time. In the same year he issued, at his own expense, De astronomicis hypothesibus, seu systemate mundano, an extensive defence of his astronomical system and priority. The work was also a deliberately provocative attack upon Brahe, employing invective that transformed a technical disagreement into a dispute over honour and actionable defamation. Beyond its polemical surface, however, the treatise addressed the historical descent and epistemological status of astronomical hypotheses, the construction of planetary models, spherical trigonometry, and observational practice.
Johannes Kepler was drawn into the controversy through a deferential letter that he had earlier written to Reimers and that Reimers printed in De astronomicis hypothesibus. After entering Brahe’s service, Kepler was required to answer Reimers’s arguments and to defend Brahe’s claim to priority. His unfinished Contra Ursum, or Apologia pro Tychone contra Ursum, consequently developed into a sustained inquiry into the nature of astronomical hypotheses, the legitimacy of physical interpretation in astronomy, and the writing of disciplinary history. Reimers’s quarrel with Brahe thus had consequences extending far beyond the immediate question of who first devised a particular geo-heliocentric diagram: it elicited from Kepler an important early reflection upon realism, evidence, historical precedent, and scientific authorship.
Brahe arrived in Prague in 1599 and pursued formal proceedings against Reimers. Preparatory documents survive, but Reimers, already gravely ill, died before the projected action could be concluded. His mathematical work continued to circulate after his death. The German Arithmetica analytica, vulgo Cosa oder Algebra, printed posthumously at Frankfurt an der Oder in 1601, belongs to the German cossic tradition and treats algebraic operations, powers, and equations. Together with the hexadecimal arithmetic of the Geodaesia, the trigonometry of the Fundamentum, and the Copernican translation preserved at Graz, it confirms that Reimers was not merely Brahe’s antagonist but a mathematically versatile intermediary between learned astronomy and vernacular practice. Subsequent historiography long viewed him through the hostile record generated by the priority dispute. More recent studies have restored the importance of his work in surveying, numerical notation, algebra, trigonometry, manuscript translation, and the circulation of astronomical knowledge across the courts and academies of northern and central Europe.
Bibliography
Jardine, Nicholas. The Birth of History and Philosophy of Science: Kepler’s “A Defence of Tycho against Ursus,” with Essays on Its Provenance and Significance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984.
Rosen, Edward. Three Imperial Mathematicians: Kepler Trapped between Tycho Brahe and Ursus. New York: Abaris Books, 1986.
Gingerich, Owen, and Robert S. Westman. The Wittich Connection: Conflict and Priority in Late Sixteenth-Century Cosmology. Transactions of the American Philosophical Society 78, pt. 7. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society, 1988.
Granada, Miguel A. El debate cosmológico en 1588: Bruno, Brahe, Rothmann, Ursus, Röslin. Naples: Bibliopolis, 1996.
Launert, Dieter. Nicolaus Reimers (Raimarus Ursus): Günstling Rantzaus—Brahes Feind. Leben und Werk. Algorismus 29. Munich: Institut für Geschichte der Naturwissenschaften, 1999.
Jardine, Nicholas, Dieter Launert, Alain-Philippe Segonds, Adam Mosley, and Karin Tybjerg. “Tycho v. Ursus: The Build-up to a Trial, Part 1.” Journal for the History of Astronomy 36, no. 1 (2005): 81–106.
Jardine, Nicholas, Katherine Harloe, Dieter Launert, and Alain-Philippe Segonds. “Tycho v. Ursus: The Build-up to a Trial, Part 2.” Journal for the History of Astronomy 36, no. 2 (2005): 125–165.
Launert, Dieter. Nicolaus Reimers Ursus: Stellenwertsystem und Algebra in der Geodaesia und Arithmetica. Nova Kepleriana, new series 9; Abhandlungen der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, new series 175. Munich: Verlag der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 2007.
Jardine, Nicholas, and Alain-Philippe Segonds. La Guerre des astronomes: La querelle au sujet de l’origine du système géo-héliocentrique à la fin du XVIe siècle. Vol. 1, Introduction. Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 2008.
Launert, Dieter. Nicolaus Reimers Ursus: Leben und Werk. 2nd, revised and expanded ed. Meldorf: Meldorfer Gelehrtenschule, 2010.
Serrano, Juan D. “Trying Ursus: A Reappraisal of the Tycho–Ursus Priority Dispute.” Journal for the History of Astronomy 44, no. 1 (2013): 17–46.
Launert, Dieter. “Ursus, Nicolaus Reimers.” In Neue Deutsche Biographie, vol. 26, 673–674. Berlin: Duncker & Humblot, 2016.
Beyond the names: biographies and bibliographies on this page are curated by Abu, the AI scholar crafted by Buonvecchio exclusively for Govi Rare Books.